Tuesday, April 15, 2014

Module 2 " IQ Tests: Dangerous or Good?"

This week one of the readings that really struck me personally was IQ tests and measuring intelligence. Woolfolk presents different perspectives on IQ tests and achievement tests. The  problem with any type of standardized test is that it only measures the students testing abilities on that given day. Some people may be good test takers while others get nervous and do not test well. Maybe the student had a headache that day and did not feel like taking a test. These tests do not take into account other factors that may influence a students ability to perform on a test on that given day. The result may be a low test score that will stay with that child forever as part of their academic file. Because of this, students are labeled as academically low, medium or high.

I have personally experienced how the results of  standardized tests can affect children's future. My son was a good student throughout grade school and high school. Took honors classes and AP classes in high school and maintained an A average. He was not a great tester when it came to Terra Nova tests, and the ACT test for college. He scored in the average range but with his abilities I felt he should be able to score higher. He went to Loyola University and graduated with a degree in Biology. Then went on for a Masters degree from Rush University. Now he is trying to get into Medical School and took the MCAT's last year. He scored only in the average range. The problem is that Medical Schools look at the MCAT score as a way to weed out the first round of applicants. They do not even look at your grades from your master's degree or even your college years until you get past the first round of applications. That does not seem fair to me. They take the score of one test taken on one day for 5 hours as the basis for granting an interview for medical school. I believe that their are so many factors that need to be taken into consideration before you can truly judge a person's true academic abilities. As a result of these kinds of tests, we brand students unfairly. This can have an impact on their self-esteem and future academic success.

4 comments:

  1. Sharon,
    Your son sounds amazing! That is incredible to hear all that he has accomplished. I am sure that it is troubling to know that he has difficulty with tests and his true abilities do not show. I did not know that about medical school, that is very unfortunate. I too agree with you that there are so many factors that go into someone's academic abilities and we cannot judge them before looking at all.
    This experiences you had in life will make you a better teacher because you have experienced first hand how these tests often do not prove anything.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sharon,

    Wow! Your son sounds familiar...

    I have major anxiety when it comes to important testing. I have been thinking about this since the moment I started at Trinity. All of the tests we take on our journey to becoming an educator are important ones, and I fear every day that I will not do well on them. I know I am a good student. I know I will be a good teacher as well. I work hard, and will research, study, and practice until I need to in order to get something right. I plan to use these traits as an educator. However, that does not get me far with testing. I only hope to do the best I can on my tests and accomplish my goal.

    I guess we need to face the facts and know that testing is a way we can get results quickly. We can help our students with self-esteem by doing our best to help them with strategies and explaining to them what they can do to calm their nerves before a test. Unfortunately, there are so many bright students out there who are probably ignored because of test results. Can we find a better way?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sharon,

    I agree completely with your assessment on IQ tests and standardized testing. As you and I spoke about in the past, I also don't do very well on tests, but I feel my abilities are right where they need to be in order to succeed. I'm sure in your son's case, this is completely the same because of the way you described how well he does academically in school and how successful he is become. In a way, I feel this all goes full circle back to labeling. At these big schools and institutions, it is all about being the best or the highest quality. All these places want to be able to proclaim they have the highest level of students coming into their schools. Just because it looks good on paper, doesn't necessarily mean they have the best of the best run through their programs, when all they are basing it on is their test scores. Hopefully, at some point in time, this will change so that everyone gets an equal chance to prove himself or herself.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sharon,
    You are very right, there are more factors that go into a persons academic success and drive besides a standardized test. I also do not do well on standardized test, and I just think they are flat out unfair for some students. Whenever I think of standardized testing I think of this quote, "If you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid." I think these types of tests can affect self-esteem and self-worth in so many ways, which with everything else students have to deal with, is completely not okay.

    ReplyDelete